“And you love Nate.”

“I never stopped,” she whispers. When she lifts her gaze to meet mine, her lashes are damp. I swear I’ve never seen anyone look so pretty from crying. “But loving someone means wanting what’s best for him, and if that’s you, I won’t confuse the issue. But if that’s not you…” She studies me for a moment. “If that’s not you, I’d really like you to step aside so my little family can have a chance.” Her voice pitches at the end, and a tear escapes and rolls down her cheek. “We are a family, you know. Despite everything. I just want to be sure you know that.”

I think of Nate’s face when he talks about Collin. How desperately he wants to be the best father possible to his son, how he’ll do anything to be part of Collin’s life. “It was nice to meet you, Vivian.” I stand and open the door to the office, motioning her out.

We walk up to the front together, and Max and my mom are at the front, chatting with Drew. Max’s face lights up when he sees me. He skims his eyes over me in a way that reminds me too well of what used to be between us.

“Hey, beautiful,” he says softly, pressing a kiss to the corner of my mouth.

Vivian’s eyes shift between us, confusion on her face. “You’ll think about what I said?” she asks. She doesn’t wait for an answer before pushing out the door and leaving.

“You can’t love someone the way they deserve when half your heart still belongs to someone else.”

I’m already thinking about it.

I thought this would be an impossible choice, but there’s only one choice that will give both of the men I love the lives they want.

I grab Max’s hand and drag him to the back and into my office.

“Are you okay?” he asks, grinning.

I push the door shut behind him and shove him against it as I press my mouth to his, searching for answers in the kiss of a man who used to be my whole world.

He doesn’t hesitate but slants his mouth over mine. His hands seek out my curves immediately, one settling on my ass, the other under my shirt just beneath my breast.

He rubs his tongue over mine, and I want to crawl into all his heat and goodness and warmth. I want this to work. I need it to.

He kisses the corner of my mouth and down the side of my neck, and a little moan escapes my lips. His grip on me loosens as he looks at me. “Marry me,” he says softly. If I thought he was releasing me, I was wrong, because the hand under my shirt skims the underside of my breast before finding the front clasp of my bra and unhooking it. “And not just because you want me as much as I want you.” Hand against my bare breast, he cups me and rolls my nipple in his fingers.

I whimper, but I make no move to escape his touch.

“Not just because I’m dying to get inside you and make you come.”

“Max,” I warn. My knees are unsteady, but when I wobble, he pulls me closer to him, still torturing my breast and making the whirl of desperate, achy, needy pleasure spiral tighter between my legs.

“The sex is going to be amazing,” he whispers, his mouth brushing my ear. “Waking up with you in my arms is going to be a dream.”

Effortlessly, he spins me and lifts me onto my desk, sending paperwork scattering across the floor as he steps between my legs. My skirt bunches at my hips, and he slides his hand up my inner thigh.

I grab his wrist and our eyes lock in that moment before my decision. I can stop him or I can let him touch me.

I lead his hand farther north. He groans as his hand connects with the damp lace of my panties. My sweet, tender Max vanishes. He tugs them to the side and sinks his fingers inside me.

I cry out, and the sound echoes in the small office. He sucks my earlobe between his teeth as his fingers pump in and out of me. If he stopped now, I’d die. I need this—and him. My heart hurts, and I need to know that this man can fill the hole Nate Crane will leave behind.

“God, I missed the way you feel wrapped around my fingers,” he groans in my ear. “So. Fucking. Sexy.”

His thumb finds my clit, and I slide my hips forward, giving him a better angle while pushing my body closer to his.

With his free hand, he yanks my shirt over my head and tosses it to the side. Then he dips his head and sucks my nipple between his teeth—as hard and relentless as the hand f**king me between my legs.

Back arched, hips bucking, hands in his hair, I come. My world shatters into a brilliant blast of light, but as it slowly pieces back together again, nothing feels like it fits.

Max runs slow, soft kisses up my neck and back to my ear. “We’re good together, Hanna. And our life together, here in New Hope? I’ll do everything in my power to make it all you ever wanted.”

I draw in a breath—thick and shaky and ragged.

Suddenly he’s holding me in his arms, murmuring, “Don’t cry,” and kissing away my tears.

I am a collection of mismatched puzzle pieces, and all I want is to feel whole.

13

“MAX! I have great news.”

I frown at my phone. Other than when she called to tell me that Hanna had decided to go ahead with the bakery with me as her anonymous investor, I don’t think my lawyer has ever left me a voicemail message with good news.

“A lawyer from California has contacted me, and her client is offering to buy you out of the bakery. The numbers she’s throwing out are almost too good to be true. They’ll more than cover the mortgage and your initial investment and leave you with a nice nest egg for your investment. As we prepare to move forward with your custody case, this would put you in a great position. I think you should take the offer. Give me a call.”